巢湖学院学报 ›› 2024, Vol. 26 ›› Issue (4): 60-66.doi: 10.12152/j.issn.1672-2868.2024.04.008

• 文学与艺术 • 上一篇    

论清代才女汪端《自然好学斋诗钞》编选中的多重才女观

幸启辰:南京师范大学 文学院   

  1. 南京师范大学 文学院,江苏 南京 210024
  • 收稿日期:2024-04-23 出版日期:2024-07-25 发布日期:2025-01-15
  • 作者简介:幸启辰(2000—),女,江苏无锡人,南京师范大学文学院硕士研究生,主要从事中国古代文学研究。

On the Multiple Views of Talented Women in the Compilation of Zi Ran Hao Xue Zhai Poems by Wang Duan, a Talented Woman of the Qing Dynasty

XING Qi-chen:College of Arts, Nanjing Normal University   

  1. College of Arts, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing Jiangsu 210024
  • Received:2024-04-23 Online:2024-07-25 Published:2025-01-15

摘要: 明清才女的别集大多为男性亲属在她们身后编定,删改的现象非常普遍。以嘉道间著名女诗人汪端的《自然好学斋诗钞》为例,在汪端去世次年道光十九年(1839)分别由夫家和母家刊刻了陈文述刻十卷本、钱塘汪氏振绮堂刻五卷本两个版本,内容相差巨大。十卷本完整收录汪端诗作,五卷本则大加删改。这两个版本塑造出汪端不同的才女形象,体现出编者陈文述、汪适孙基于不同立场的才女观。陈文述将个人情怀、自我认同寄托于才女和女性文本,汪适孙则强调才女及其作品的家族和地域认同。汪适孙在删选诗集时暗中淡化陈家痕迹,凸显汪家存在,可视为这两种才女观在女性别集编选这一场域的角力。

关键词: 女性别集, 才女观, 汪端, 《自然好学斋诗钞》

Abstract: The poetry collections of talented women in the Ming and Qing dynasties were mostly compiled by their male relatives, and the phenomenon of deletion and modification was very common. Taking the famous female poet Wang Duan's Zi Ran Hao Xue Zhai Poems as an example, in the year following her death, which was the nineteenth year of the Daoguang reign (1839), her husband's family and her natal family respectively published two versions: a ten-volume edition by Chen Wenshu and a five-volume edition by the Wang family's Zhen Qi Tang, with significant differences in content. The ten-volume edition fully includes Wang Duan's poetry, while the fivevolume edition has many deletions and modifications. These two versions create different images of Wang Duan, reflecting the views of editors Chen Wenshu and Wang Shisun based on different perspectives. Chen Wenshu placed personal feelings and self-identity on talented women and female texts, while Wang Shisun emphasized family and regional identity in relation to talented women and their works. Wang Shisun subtly downplayed the traces of the Chen family and highlighted the presence of the Wang family when editing the poetry collection, which can be seen as a struggle between these two views on talented women in the field of female poetry collection compilation.

Key words: collected female works, views of talented women, Wang Duan, Zi Ran Hao Xue Zhai Poems

中图分类号: 

  • I206.2